Monday, October 21, 2024

Which college degrees are worth the most?

I saw this over at ZeroHedge
 
These two entries caught my eye
Net Present Worth assumes a few things. For one thing, it assumes some level of income change over time, generally with pay increasing. Sometimes that is a bad assumption if the degree is trendy and the jobs are over-subscribed.

Another major issue that can get lost in the weeds is that many people who get a degree don't get a job in their field...or don't get ANY job. How do you handle those people? Most surveys ignore them.

The two areas-of-study that I circled are likely to suffer from both of those issues. "Professional journalists" are nearly extinct and AECGGS is such a recent invention that it is foolhardy to assume there is any organic demand for the graduates.

14 comments:

  1. Don't ignore the side benefits. Having a career that you LOVE to do can save money in the long run due to less stress and less medical needs over time. When you are content with how you spend 9 hours of your time outside the house, a lot of home life falls into place.

    I'm an architectural CAD draftsman. It doesn't pay much, but I enjoy time creating structures, especially walking through them as they are being built. Rarely boring.

    The challenges (like most jobs) are the people you have to deal with. Clients who want to cut cost. Contractors who want speed in building. City Departments who want to stick to letter of law. Keeping a lot of balls in the air.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I am surprised that you didn't mention "change orders" aka "late revisions" as an aggravation.

      The four corners of the Project Management pyramid are cost, timing, deliverables and risk.

      Delete
  2. Currently as I see it the best paying degree is political connections.

    Like the Longshoremen Union, having an IN gets you into membership.

    In work best enjoyed I find plumbers and electricians most happy around here. Their work is always in demand, they share information about deadbeats so better PAY your Bill buddy and they have enough toys and TIME OFF to enjoy them.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. There is a rumor going around that Elon Musk is working on an invention to make plumbers obsolete.

      He noticed all of the shit going into people's heads via WIFI and is working on a way to make it go in reverse.

      Delete
    2. Musk is pretty good, but Einstein said something about stupidity being infinite and he wasn't sure about the galaxy being so.

      Delete
  3. I got a B of A in Graphic Design in 1996. Started out making 20+/hr straight outta college. People wanted to hire me b/c I had that piece of paper alone.
    Today that job pays 15-18/hr in my AO. Still want the paper, and 5 years experience now, too.
    My CDL license gets me jobs in the 22-25/hr range, and cost nothing (earned while working).

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Most "advisors" in US high schools should be sued for malpractice.

      "Follow your passions. There will be a job for you." They pander to whatever whim the student projects. "Sure you can be a world-class, theoretical astro-physicist. Your 2.2/4.0 GPA in math won't be any problem. Einstein had bad grades too."

      Delete
    2. Funnily enough... I was interested in and liked the mechanical drafting classes I was taking in HS, but society at large and my advisor said you have to find something you Love, b/c you'll be doing it for 40 years. Graphic designing was more fun than drawing gears and floor plans, but I know all too well which would have been a better career choice.

      Delete
  4. Somehow it is sad that foreign language qualifications are right down at the bottom.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The bottom of that job-market fell out when Google Translate became "good enough". Now there are hand-helds and smartphone apps that do voice-to-text-to-translate in near-real-time. Why hire somebody for 40 minute-a-week of translation when you can use the app and get 95 percent of the functionality?

      The value of a translator (especially if the other party is not aware of their capability) is that he can capture the side-conversations during negotiations.

      Delete
  5. I graduated very long ago with one of those not-worth-much degrees (from WMU) and got a job with Chevy. I saw the light and got one of those degrees at the high end (back when a college degree meant something). Paid for it myself. Lost 5 years but got smart in time and the pay difference didn't take long to recover expenses.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thats the one positive to my B of A.... I've advanced to mgmt very quickly in other endeavors, my papers being a reason cited.

      Delete
  6. ERJ, I am one of those people that did not get a job in the field for which I studied in either my undergraduate or graduate degree. That said, I have managed to do uncommonly well due to the fact I landed in an industry where I could learn as I go and the overall trend is good.

    I do wonder if in some cases new graduates spend too much time looking at the what rather than the where. I should think that degrees that overlap the what and the where (for example, education where many people enter teaching or journalism where many people assume they will be "writers") it becomes difficult as there are too many bodies for too few positions - and those sorts of degrees may not teach such things as "how to use your degree outside of your major".

    In fact, that is a failing of many higher education institutions: they care for getting students through the system, not what happens to them afterwards.

    ReplyDelete
  7. So the least profitable degrees run the government and control media. Is power more important in the long game?

    ReplyDelete

Readers who are willing to comment make this a better blog. Civil dialog is a valuable thing.