Wind gusts of up to 53 mph are forecast for today.
One of the concerns about not burying the legs is diminished resistance to tipping over during high winds. I decided to dust off my engineering skills and see if I could ***ESTIMATE*** tipping resistance.
The critical velocity is calculated by setting the "righting moment" equal to the (wind drag TIMES sail height) and solving for V.
The "righting moment" is the narrowest dimension of the base, times the weight AND divided by two. The reason for dividing by two is because the center-of-gravity is probably centered, thus exploiting only half the footprint's capability.
The wind drag is 1/2 * Velocity^2 * air density(slugs/ft^3) * drag coefficient (which is between 1.3 and 2.0 for a flat plate when oblique to the wind direction). The sail height is the height of the center of the structure. In this case the floor is 10.5 feet above the ground and the roof will be 18.5 feet above the ground. Average height will be 14.5 feet.
A little bit a algebra and accumulating of coefficients yields something like:
Vmphtipping = sqrt (142 * weight * narrowest footprint(ft) / sail area (ft^2) / sail height). Plugging in the numbers for my elevated blind (estimating 500 pound weight) indicates the possibility of tipping over at 21 mph gusts.
NOT. GOOD. ENOUGH.
Clearly, some system of guy-wires or additional support is needed.
In cases like this, Excel is your friend. A 60 mph gust produces a tipping moment of about 5500 ft-lbs. A guy-line attached to the top of one of the pilings (approximately 10 feet above the ground) needs to withstand about 350 pounds of tension (in addition to the righting moment of the weight) to counteract that tipping force.
It looks like I will be burying some rebar and concrete and stretching some guy-line before I put any more sheathing on the frame.
No problem. Get a dirt auger anchor, like they use to tie down mobile homes. Screw it in the ground directly in the center, between the legs. Tie that to the center bottom of the deer blind. I've been using this method for years, and my blinds withstand hurricane force winds. If a tornado hits it, all bets are off.
ReplyDeletePawpaw, you are blessed to live somewhere that has plenty of soil soft enough to do that. Where I usually hunt in west Texas, dirt is usually about 4" deep and then nothing but thick beds of limestone for many feet. Our guy wires usually get tied to some scrubby little trees whose roots have managed to pry their way a few feet into the limestone over many years. Your method would require hiring an expensive rig and getting him to the lease would be no small feat either due to the remote locations and bad access roads. Location, location, location!
DeleteHello Pawpaw and 6ShotsOr5. The auger is a good idea but I think I can bury a concrete anchor more cheaply. It comes down to cost.
DeleteGreat information....thanks for reading and thanks for taking the time to make informative, useful comments.