Monday, September 14, 2026

Where does the education dollar go and Emergency Room visits

From the annual budgets of a local school district. The average over the last three budget years. Expressed on a per-pupil basis.

It is interesting that the cost of fringe benefits are about 70% of the cost of salaries.

Emergency Room visits

Source

The image shown above has a great deal of information in it. The headers are "Primary Reason" for going to the Emergency Room and they are numbered 1-through-16 which is their rank-order of in terms of frequency. The number in parenthesis in the headers is the "Coding number" and not the number of times it occurred.

The horizontal axis is broken into age groups and the squiggle-line is the percentage of ER visits with that primary cause that results in a hospital admission.

The text in the paper informs us that some admissions (especially for older patients) are because there is nobody at home who can care for them. Vertigo is a good example. They need somebody to help toilet them and if there is nobody there, then they get admitted. A higher percentage of seniors get admitted for vertigo than younger people not because it is more severe but because they are less likely to have support at home and because falling is a higher probability event and the consequences of falling is more severe.

In general, there is a bit of a knee in the curve at age 50 where the likelihood of being hospitalized from an ER visit ramps up more rapidly than between 1-and-50 years of age.

From anecdotal information, constipation is the "high runner" for abdominal pain (the most common "primary reason" given by patients). Women are between 1.5X and 4.0X more likely to suffer from constipation than men.

Studies with more than 10,000 subjects are highlighted. Source

 Controllable factors that contribute to constipation include

  • Inadequate water intake
  • Inadequate fiber
  • Inadequate moving around
  • Resisting the urge to defecate when our body tells us it is time 

It is easy to see that the corporate office work-model contributed to the gender disparity. The first study listed (1.82:1 disparity) was in the mid-1960s when fewer women were in the paid workforce and more of the jobs involved physical movement. Later studies, like the Harari, NHIS study (3.77:1 disparity) were conduced in the mid-1990s when more women were working office jobs and sat at computer monitors or answered phone-calls all day long. Many women strongly dislike using public restrooms.

Sidenote: I stumbled across several peer-reviewed papers about "gender equity in healthcare". The authors were criticizing Emergency Room personnel because they were much less likely to give women opioid's for abdominal pain then men. Clearly, these were Gender Study majors rather than Healthcare professionals. Morphine and other opioids are strongly counter-indicated for constipation because they reduce gut motility, i.e. they paralyze the gut.

Opioids should not be administered before a diagnosis has been done because it can make the underlying issue worse or make diagnosis more difficult. 

Applesauce

Yesterday was an "applesauce" day. Sixteen quarts were canned and now sitting on shelves in the pantry.

9 comments:

  1. Seems we were made to walk around and DO things.

    Sitting and avoiding "public bathrooms" (sigh my wife also) doesn't help bowel health.

    Opioids for bowel pain GAAAAK...

    ReplyDelete
  2. I really get irked when I’ve called my doctors office with a problem, and they tell me no appointments are available for several weeks, and I should go to the ER. Several of the issues on those charts could be treated by a primary, instead of tying up the ER.
    It used to be I could get see my doc in a few days, or sooner, for something like rash, or cough.
    Southern NH

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. General Practitioners are understaffed because they don't get paid as much as "specialties". Unlike a specialist, they can't pop their head into 10 hospital rooms, initial a chart and then bill ten "consultation fees" (with a portion of that going to the hospital). GPs are also relatively at-risk for malpractice suites.

      In theory, the GP is the gate-keeper to the very expensive end of the healthcare system but the system penalizes them from a pay standpoint so they are MIA.

      FWIW, 101 Ways to Save Money on Health Care: Tips to Help You Spend Smart and Stay Healthy by Cynthia Koelker is a great book.
      Our healthcare system is profoundly broken.

      Delete
    2. My wife fired her primary care doctor just because of that. She would be explaining a problem to her doc and she would tell her ; Well, you'll have to go to the ER for that. Primary care docs only do "wellness checks" now to collect the insurance check.

      She just signed up with a Healthcare company that does house calls, providing doctors and nurse practitioners that can write prescriptions as needed and give referrals if warranted.

      Delete
  3. My wife doesn't walk so constipation is an ongoing battle. She tops it off by not drinking enough water. Fiber increase without enough water just makes things worse. The thing that seems to work best is a Culvers Butterburger with cheese. I think it is the fat content. I doubt Culvers will start a new ad campaign based on this fact.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I had a co-worker named Charlie whose wife put him on a diet. He immediately bound up.

      Things improved immensely after he resumed eating his morning donut. He was convinced that he needed a little bit of fat in his diet to "grease the system".

      So, I 100% believe you.

      One of my buddies (now deceased) put three bottles of water on the counter for his wife. One of them had to be empty by 10:00 AM. The next by 1:00 and the third by 4:00.

      Delete
  4. It was a mess before, but the government has absolutely completely and totally fucked up the medical insurance marketplace, and as a result, the medical industry as a whole. It has reached the point of being non-functional, as the patient health is no longer the primary concern (I could argue it never was, but we've reached past a tipping point now).
    Get the federal government out of the whole shebang NOW.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Both constipation and vertigo can be caused by chronic dehydration, and older adults are much more prone to (chronic) dehydration.

    For kids and young adults, seems that for the most part vertigo is a side-effect of a particularly bad flu or other illness, rather than as a free-standing condition suffered on its own?

    As for the General Practitioner versus Emergency Room anecdote, I wonder if ER visit causes/frequency have changed with the rise of "Urgent Care" facilities? These basically fill some of the gap between GP and ER (and also are generally priced somewhere in between the $$$ of going to a GP and the $$$$$ of an ER visit)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Right now, my wife is bedridden with a compression fracture in her back. She's on opiates for pain and constipation is a big worry. I've got her to lay off the Pepsi and drink more water.

      Trying to see if we can get her in a short term rehab facility. After three days, we figured out that I'm not really able to take care of her in this condition.

      Delete

Readers who are willing to comment make this a better blog. Civil dialog is a valuable thing.