I am praying for the people of the LDS church in Grand Blanc, Michigan that was attacked on Sunday.
This hits pretty close to home, both geographically and personally. I am one of our church's "greeters". That is, I stand by the door and welcome people.
For some people, it might be the only "happy" human contact they receive all week. There is one 82 year-old widow who I hug every time she comes to church.
I know that my readers have a vast range of experiences. So I have a question for you:
If I am standing at the door and I see the door being approached by a madman carrying a firearm...do I hit the fire-alarm?
Reasons to do it:
- It will empty the building
- The loud, audible alarm is likely to unnerve the gunman. He might abort the mission.
- It will trigger 9-1-1 response and get EMS rolling toward the building
- Anybody who is "carrying" will be heads-up. I don't expect anybody would be carrying because Lansing Diocese prohibits the carrying of firearms on their property.
Reasons not to do it:
- First responders are likely to be firefighters. They will be at-risk from the gunman
- Hitting the fire-alarm might be flushing the quail and making the gunman's job easier.
Mitigating factors
- There will be a crowd of people fleeing the facility and might halt fire-response outside of the danger zone.
- Police sometimes respond to "fire alarms" to provide crowd control. If they are available, they would likely be among the first to arrive when a crowded building like a church is on-fire.
- People will be calling 9-1-1 and adding detail to the unfolding crisis. 9-1-1 operator will tell the fire-crew that the site is NOT SECURE and they will stage about 200 yards away from the grounds.
Any thoughts?
Triggering a 1st responder response as quickly as possible seems to be very prudent to me.
ReplyDeleteSpecifics can be argued ad-infinitum, armchair quarterbacks will Monday Morning the incident no matter what. Getting the ball rolling is still a highly effective strategy, if you're not taking a knee to steady your aim first.
Fire Alarm triggers call to action. Agree that would probably worry the shooter and make him-her-them flee in panic. Not part of the plan in their mind.
ReplyDeleteI think many first responders are aware they could be walking into a trap. Arriving and finding many outside would probably reassure them the emergency is real.
Good Question !
Yes, thought. Carry anyway, concealed, but carry. Screw the Lansing Diocese. Christ and God never told anyone to be STUPID.
ReplyDelete