"Enough" is a powerful concept.
Figuring out how much is "Enough" is not as obvious as it appears.
1858 New Army Remington
I got to shoot an 1858 New Army Remington replica today.
It was the Pietta version and we had some nipple-cap issues, but that was anticipated. The owner has new nipples for #11 caps (the easiest ones to find locally) coming. Five of the nipples cheerfully held their caps. One would not.
By-the-numbers:
| Source |
A .357 Magnum case holds 1.7cc of volume which converts to "25 grains by volume" of blackpowder.
25 grains of FFFG Triple Seven "by volume" can be expected to push a 140 grain, .454" lead, round-ball somewhere between 750 and 790 fps. 25 grains-by-volume of FFFG pencils out to 300 rounds per pound of Triple Seven.
35 grains of Pyrodex P can be expected to push the same ball at 900 fps.
The first load is the equivalent of a wadcutter target load out of a .38 Special and the second load is the equivalent of a "combat" load out of a snubby .38 Special.
A 1858 with a 5-1/2" barrel tips the scale at 40 ounces which is almost exactly twice what a steel-framed, .38 Special "snubby" weighs.
The recoil on the 1858 is negligible, the sights are "fine" and the trigger is lovely.
If a .38 Special loaded with wadcutters is "just enough", it is hard to argue that a 0.45" diameter ball of the same weight and velocity is totally inadequate. Even if you might wish for a bit more, it still beats a harshly worded memo when things go bump-in-the-night.
The Pietta 1858 has parking-notches in the cylinder between the nipples. You can park your hammer in any of the notches to keep it off a percussion cap and avoid accidental firing if the weapon is dropped.
If push-came-to-shove and the mission was to shoot across the width of your bedroom at somebody who busted through your bedroom door, an 1858 New Army replica in .44 would be "enough" if you could keep the caps on the nipples. By the same token, if you needed to pot a deer at 15 yards, you would still have "enough" as long as you restricted yourself to broadside "lung" shots.
It will never be a "Magnum". It doesn't have enough steel in the right places to support those kinds of pressure. But within the envelop of what it is, it performs well.
As a side note, if you look at the cost of shooting one of these beasts on a per-hour basis, you will be hard pressed to find a more economical gun. It is entirely possible to burn through 100 rounds of ammo in a semi-auto in ten minutes if you have enough magazines. That same 100 rounds would last you for HOURS and HOURS in a replica blackpowder pistol. And since you have so much invested in loading it, you are more likely to slow-down and attempt to learn more each time you pull the trigger.
Bonus video Shooting pop cans at 21 yards after adjusting the sight. Not me nor my buddy. Just a video found on the internet.
Notes: The chamber for the Pietta is 22.8mm from the mouth to where the wall breaks for the angle of the drill bit. It measures 11.2mm in diameter.
Internal volume is 2.2CC plus the volume for the drilled-and-tapped hole for the nipple.
1.7CC FFFG Triple Seven is 25 volume-grains equivalent and weighs 22.7 grains by weight. 23 grains of FFFG Triple Seven + 0.7 CC of turnip seeds plus a 3mm greased felt wad (0.3CC volume) plus a 0.451" pure lead ball makes a good "package".











