Sunday, October 29, 2023

Physical fitness report and thoughts on brooms

The good news is that I was able to run 4.5 miles yesterday in 53 minutes. I would love to get down to 10 minute miles but just being able to crank out 4.5 miles (with an additional half-mile walk-down) was thrilling.

In other good news, I found a neighbor who is willing to take the steer to the slaughter house and is interested in keeping the two heifers for breeding stock. He is even willing to coordinate with the butcher-shop so I don't have to get in the middle of playing "telephone". Life just got much, much better for me.

The bad news is that the ticks were active with our unseasonably warm weather. That will come to a screeching halt tomorrow.

"...empty, swept clean and put in order..."

 “When an unclean spirit goes out of a person it roams through arid regions searching for rest but finds none. Then it says, ‘I will return to my home from which I came.’ But upon returning, it finds it empty, swept clean, and put in order. Then it goes and brings back with itself seven other spirits more evil than itself, and they move in and dwell there; and the last condition of that person is worse than the first. Thus it will be with this evil generation.”   Matt 12:43-45

I chose to write about this passage because I think it might contain practical tips for dealing with the demons of our times.

This passage is ambiguous and can be read many different ways. Depending upon the way it is read, it will lead the modern reader into very different places. Consequently, most people studying this passage skim over it and put it aside for later study.

The reason the passage is ambiguous is because the author assumes that the reader has access to context that was obvious to those who were listening at the time and was probably ubiquitous to the time-and-place when Jesus said those words. Where I need to tippy-toe is that I will be speculating with regard to what cannot be known with certainty. What follows in this post is speculation about particulars that are not key matters of faith. If that bothers you, please stop reading.

Mental Health

It seems probable to me that "...demons..." were frequently referenced when describing why people with major, mental-illnesses behaved the way they did.

Even today, "...demons..." is about as useful of an explanation for some illnesses as what modern medical science offers: Bipolar, Multiple personality disorders, Psychosis (hearing voices) and so on.

Mental illnesses are perplexing to treat because one dysfunction seems to trigger other dysfunctions in a cascading avalanche of failures. ADHD triggers Anxiety which triggers Depression which triggers Oppositional defiance disorder which triggers Bipolar which...

People living in Biblical times would be keenly aware of the other people living in their village. Economically (as in calories/day) the vast majority of people were living on the knife's edge of just-enough and any neighbor who became possessed by demons represented a major threat to their economic lifeboat. Remember, one impulsive emotion-triggered thrust of a burning stick could burn down the entire village or destroy a ripe field of grain.

Standard of Care for mental illness, circa Year Twenty-five Common Era

I believe that the lost bit of ubiquitous information is that the cleaning of the house and putting in order was the "Standard of Care" for mental illness in the Biblical era.

Seen through the lens of what we think we know about mental-illness, it is not a bad strategy.

Simple, repetitive tasks like sweeping or counting or reciting the multiplication tables act as a metronome and slows the rapid-fire, staccato, over-revving mind and anxieties. Marsha Linehan called this "getting into 'wise-mind'".

The tangible act of sorting the important from that-which-should-be-discarded is a physical analog of what needs to be done mentally and emotionally. Frankly, how much mental illness is triggered or worsened by toxic, legacy relationships that should have been  discarded decades ago or by items that trigger guilt that is impossible to resolve (at this point)?

The cleaning-and-sorting process is also therapeutic because two objects cannot occupy the same space on the shelf. Likewise, two objectives cannot share the same priority. One cannot have one's cake and eat it at the same time. Human minds lock-up when the owner of the cake cannot decide which priority is more important. The act of cleaning informs us that we have to pick ONE item to put on the shelf. We can live with it for a while. We can change our minds at a later time. But to clean the room we have to make a decision NOW.

But what about the seven other demons, more evil than the first?

Even with modern therapies and modern drugs, treatments for mental illness do not always work.

I think the "seven demons more evil than itself" is a description of the cascading avalanche described a few paragraphs earlier.

At the level of society?

The strategies might be scalable to address the craziness we see in the streets of our nation.

Water cannons can be used instead of brooms. Those who attack the people cleaning the streets are not bulletproof. Access to entitlements should be swiftly denied to those who fail to behave in civilized ways. If they have children, the children should be placed in homes where the adults are civilized and the entitlements should follow the children.

If the people who are violent in the streets work in the public sector, they should be summarily fired. If they cannot be fired due to contractual reasons, then funding from the state and federal levels should be removed to the extent of 2X that persons gross cost of employment.

The difference between the village in the time of Christ and the cities of today is that it would take lot longer to rebuild the cities of today and the body count would be much, much higher.

If men of good character do not step-up then the demons will prevail. Fixing this is not difficult. Discarding toxic beliefs and fuzzy, feel-good theories that we cherish is what is difficult.

8 comments:

  1. Great job on the run, ERJ - especially with the year you have had! I actually just got a new pair of running shoes as I need to re-start running as well.

    Interesting meditation. I had not thought of the risk to the community aspect, but you are completely right: one unfortunate move and the entire years harvest could be at risk.

    I am coming to terms with the fact that I can only, ever, have one thing going in my mind at a time. For years I tried to work and believe and convince myself that I could have multi-task; I have met people that can. Not for me. I am single thought/action guy.

    Eliminating/reducing funding: this is a brilliant idea keeping the collective accountable. It then does not become parents or societal members, but their colleagues.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Four and a half miles in less than an hour - Awesome ! That takes perseverence and you appear to have that in spades.

    Teachers should be measured on how well they teach their students the mandated materials. Social Justice are opinions and can be discussed in class so long as equal time given for opposing opinions are given. Without discussion, there can be no learning.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I always ‘interpreted’ Matt 12:43-45 as alluding to the G. K. Chesterton (Father Brown) quote “when men cease to believe in God they do not then believe in nothing, but in anything”, otherwise known by the saying of “don’t throw the baby out with the bath-water”. That a house “empty, swept clean and put in order”, an empty, vacant vessel, without foundation, history, faith, is not a ‘good thing’ but an ‘invitation to evil’.

    Having professional contact (as an ER nurse) over the years, and as I grow older, I suspect that mental health ‘issues’ are not just more common than we assume, but almost universal (there are, unfortunately, not too many Saints out there). That what we describe as ‘having a mental health illness’ is merely a matter of degree, not some ‘new’ addition.

    We are social creatures. What is “normal”? I still resort to Pratchett’s description (a man of some ‘doubtful’ political beliefs, but an astute observer of … ‘people’ nevertheless):

    “It was later said that he came under a bad influence at this stage. But the secret of the history of Edward d'Eath was that he came under no outside influence at all, unless you count those dead kings. He just came under the influence of himself.

    That's where people get it wrong. Individuals aren't naturally paid-up members of the human race, except biologically. They need to be bounced around by the Brownian motion of society, which is a mechanism by which human beings constantly remind one another that they are... well... human beings. He was also spiraling inwards, as tends to happen in cases like this.”

    ― Terry Pratchett, Men at Arms

    The problem is then compounded when such individuals ‘congregate’ and ‘support’ each others “madness”. The don’t just support, but encourage and drive each other to new extremes, and … ‘infect’ others exposed to them (under their power and influence).

    That, I suspect, is why the, apparently, ever growing numbers with mental health issues? Why the, obvious, fact that almost all ‘our’ institutions are now, not just run by/for these people, but entirely made up of them.

    The (deliberate) removal of God from their lives, that they exist in an ‘ivory tower’ or an ‘exclusionary bubble’ where they are only, will only have contact with others ‘exactly like them’, goes a long way to explain these … “activists”. And the fact that the Venn diagram of mental health issues, activism (of whatever kind), and … employment in an ‘official institution’ can be seen to be almost entirely overlapping circles. Throw in the fact that our “welfare society” ‘allows’ them to exist (not many mentally ill where you ‘have’ to work hard 18 hr days to eat, and no-one cares if daddy didn’t buy you a pony) and I suspect this will only stop when … it can no longer continue.



    [Apologies for the quotes. As I ‘age’ I find, more and more, that everything I want to say, someone else already said … but better. So it’s Bible, Shakespeare, occasionally authors such as Pratchett and … eighties song lyrics for some reason. Be grateful I didn’t quote those!]

    ReplyDelete
  4. Excellent topic Joe.

    Much in agreement on the "cascading" effect.
    Liked the "analysis" of Matt 12. I've long thought most biblical text is FAR more of a practical bent than folks are willing to accept. So many desperately want the supernatural at every turn & twist. I just kind shrug at that.

    I'm like my Croatian grandfather.... when seeing poor behavior by people he would shake his head & snort, "cabbage!".

    Going out in public poorly dressed, poorly behaved, acting a fool when accompanying a woman or too loud was just "cabbage" behavior. Being abusive or cussing in public was grounds for some not so gentle handling.

    Don't know how or where he came up with the saying but after his passing it was a "go to" comment in our family. EVERYONE KNEW what it implied.

    You don't want to be "cabbage"!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. My Swedish grandfather and sheriff of 20 years used the term "pot licker". In his eyes, pot lickers were lower than whale sh*t, and that is at the bottom of the ocean.

      Delete
    2. We call people who come to our customer events but never buy anything "plate lickers". When we identify them they get removed from the next year's lists.

      Delete
  5. Congrats on the run! And interesting take on Matthew 12. I need to go think about that.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Regarding Matthew 12 - may I recommend a book by Jonathan
    Cahn - "THE RETURN OF THE GODS". He has a slightly different take on it. He has launched me into a long thought process on this subject.










    R




    ReplyDelete

Readers who are willing to comment make this a better blog. Civil dialog is a valuable thing.