Friday, June 26, 2026

Miss Daisy report and "What is a gallon of gas worth?"

Driving Miss Daisy went fine.

I was able to negotiate the hazards of East Lansing traffic and I killed some of the time in the bagel shop next to the PT shop. I ate a chocolate-cheesecake muffin and people-watched while waiting.

Miss Daisy is very pleased with the intake session and with her PT person. The PT person was overwhelmingly positive. "Oh! You have excellent muscle tone." and "Very good baseline range-of-motion".

It is awesome when a patient goes into PT and they are not starting from 200 yards behind the starting-line.

Oil

I got to thinking about what five gallons of gasoline or diesel fuel is worth.

Back in the middle-1980s, automotive engines that had BSFC numbers of 0.40 pound of fuel consumption per horsepower-hour were as common as house-flies. Small engines are inherently less efficient because they lose more heat to heads and cylinder walls relative to engines with larger cylinders. The "adiabatic" i.e., no heat loss, expansion of the heated gasses in the cylinder are less-adiabatic.

Since I am too time-stressed to research BSFC numbers for small engines, let's assume that the best you can do is about 0.60 pounds of fuel per horse-power hour.

A gallon of gas weighs about six pounds.  Six divided by 0.60 gives you an upper-limit of 10 horsepower-hours of work. 

A gallon of diesel weights seven pounds and the engines are potentially more efficient because their greater compression ratio can squeeze more "adiabatic expansion" out of each cycle.

This is not a traditional BSFC map. It charts thermodynamic efficiency. Most efficient region is the gray plateau on the upper-right portion of the surface. Idling and partial load are the narrow strips in the lower-center portion.

Matching the load to the engine's output is a major issue. Peak efficiency is only achieved at relatively high loading. That is, near open throttle at medium-to-high RPM. 

A motor powering a generator that has little load will not give you 10 hp-hr per gallon of gas! A motor running an irrigation-pump (continuous duty) that is intelligently sized for the application will come close to giving you 10 hp-hr per gallon. Most other applications will fall somewhere in the middle.

Food/gardening

The decal on the engine that drives my rototiller claims to be a 6.5hp engine.

It rarely takes all 6.5hp to move the tines of the tiller through the soil. Consequently, I am not going to get the work of one-horse cultivating soil for ten hours out of one gallon of gas.

However, I might get the equivalent amount of work of a horse working for three hours cultivating. An added bonus of the tiller is that it takes less space to maneuver it at the ends of the rows. That is a big deal when you have to fence your garden against wildlife.

And that jibes fairly closely to what I see in terms of how often I have to fill the gas tank. I need to refill the gallon tank after every three times I use it for weed-control where it is a quick, shallow pass and the soil is not laced with mature, woody, plant roots.

Five gallons of fuel, if dedicated to running a tiller, would be more than enough to keep a very large garden mostly weed-free for the growing season. How large? 

If two gallons of gas is enough for six passes with the tiller over 6000 square feet of midwestern loam, then five gallons of gas would suffice for 15,000 square-feet or 1/3 of an acre. That should be more than enough to keep a family of six in vegetables even if the rains were not-the-best.

If the rains ARE good, there will also be a surplus that can be shared with family or traded for other items that are needed. 

11 comments:

  1. When I was heating with wood, I found that between the chainsaw and the wood splitter, I was using about 4 gallons of gas a year to get my wood.
    Jonathan

    ReplyDelete
  2. Interesting the gallon of gasoline value since you brought that up a few posts ago with the Eastern European farmer who was irrigating with a gasoline powered pump.

    Then you spoke of its cost and how much of that family's annual cash flow that gasoline represented.

    In his case the math worked, the cost of gasoline gave his family more harvest to eat (deferred costs not having to buy it) and extra crops to sell to generate money.

    If the 1973 oil crisis odd-even gasoline rationing occurs again because of Epstein's Fury, we will again realize the value of a gallon of gasoline.

    Seafoam gasoline treatment is nice.

    ReplyDelete
  3. ERJ - The only fuel I use right now if for the car. I am interested in eyeballing fuel usage (as opposed to my mileage).

    In an average month where I commute work and the gym, I can easily have a tank last over a month. If I add on commuting to my Iaijutsu class once a week, that cuts it down to about a month (although, paranoid me, I refuel at half a tank).

    ReplyDelete
  4. The concern I invariably come back to with these situations, is what if, fuel simply becomes unobtanium for whatever reason, and whatever length of time?
    Obviously something months/weeks is different than years, but I still find the same conclusion - Diesel is the answer. You can make it from used vegetable oil, or gas+motor oil, or... a variety of forms of fuel will burn, albeit at varying efficiencies, in a diesel engine. Gasoline is difficult to store and transport (flashes), much more difficult to refine, and decidedly geared towards civilian uses? Diesel is used by the military vehicles, commerical transport.. if fuel services every become degraded and/or scarce, diesel, or some substitute, is likely to be available before gasoline, or like fuels.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The heating oil that my friend was salvaging from an in-ground tank got me to thinking about this topic.

      I saw a Project Farm video where the dude (great guy!) ran a mower with 50:50 gasoline:diesel. It was a low-compression, NOT overhead valve engine so it was OK with distillate.

      It didn't start easily.

      I don't advise adding diesel to gasoline to be used in an OHV engine unless there was some way to verify the octane.

      There are Chinesium diesel engines with a 3 horsepower engine being approximately the same size and weight as a 6.5hp gasoline engine.

      Delete
    2. As I recall, one issue with misfuelling diesel cars is that the gas (petrol) wrecks the lubrication that diesel fuels provide, and can be very expensive to fix. Do these alternatives - chip fat, vegetable oils etc provide the necessary lubrication to avoid problems?

      Delete
    3. The Project Farm video (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PXLWLXz0iY4) is running gasoline-diesel in a gasoline engine with a 6:1 compression ratio.

      It is my understanding that modern fuel injector tips have exotic coatings like titanium nitride sputter-coating to resist wear. Germany, for historical reasons, has been almost paranoid about being able to run their economy with synthetic lubricants and biodiesel synthesized from rape-seed oil.

      One factor that makes that a possibility is that the EPA and the Euro equivalent drove the fuel producers to eliminate most of the sulfur from diesel fuel. Sulfur compounds are natural high-pressure lubricating additives. The suppliers who produce the pumps and injectors had to make design changes.

      Farmers running legacy equipment have the option of purchasing fuel additives that contain sulfur to extend the life of their equipment.

      Delete
    4. ...China and India still produces high-sulfur diesel. It might be worth considering using the sulfur containing, extreme pressure additive if you run a Chinesium engine.

      Delete
  5. Research wood gasification. It was a thing during WWII… it’s still a thing today, just not very common.
    -In Muskegon

    ReplyDelete
  6. Re wood gasification please remember the free FEMA plans for one isn't the best design available. No fuel filtering, very hard on engines.

    U-tube has plenty of older videos showing real folks driving wood gas vehicles and much better plans.

    Expect about a 50% reduction of power from your engines on properly made and filtered wood gas. I met at a Mother Earth Fair the gentleman that wood gassed his V8 pickup truck. Was fun to drive :-) but a little sluggish acceleration.

    Joe realistically as you're the engineer type what % of your tillers 6.5 HP gasoline engine's potential is used? Obviously bogging down a gasoline engine isn't a good thing but if a smaller say 3 hp tillers could do it then some of the larger corded electrics could do it and a garden shed with solar panels might be useful as you'd have several days between uses?

    Also, you could have motion detecting lights so powered to give the night critters a startle. A neighbor has a solar garden shed and a motion detection unit that sprays water. Deer seems to hate her garden :-)

    I've worked a smaller truck garden without power tools but I'm not that young now.

    ReplyDelete

Readers who are willing to comment make this a better blog. Civil dialog is a valuable thing.