Where the stories start...

Sunday, May 31, 2026

Red, clay soils

Note: This essay is what I think I know about growing plants in the south. Hopefully, Lucky will chime in and correct my errors.



Early studies of nutrient cycling in moist tropical forests describes productive forests rich in nutrients in which the rates of primary production (photosynthesis) and amounts of nutrients cycled clearly exceeded those in temperate zone forests. Reviews of global-scale patterns in biomass, production and nutrients cycling reported these results as representative of tropical forests.

At the same time, tropical forest soils were described as acide, infertile clay that hardens irreversibly to “laterite” when cleared or to bleached, quartz sands low in mineral nutrients. This apparent paradox was crystalized by Whittaker in the statement “The tropical rain forest thus has a relatively rich nutrient economy perched on a nutrient-poor substrate.”
P.M. Vitousek and R.L. Sanford, 1986

The forest floor in the tropics teem with termites, ants, terrestrial crabs, centipedes, snails, slugs and similar scavengers. A piece of snake feces falling from the canopy and hitting the ground is cleaned up within minutes. A leaf or twig might be gone in a day or a week.

Due to the heat and humidity, organic material quickly decays and release their nutrients. The dense webbing of feeder roots just below the surface are in a life-or-death battle to grab those nutrients before some other tree does or (unlikely) the nutrient is leached out of the reach of the roots.

The red, clay soils in the southeastern United States have many similarities with the soils in the tropics. 

How to manage gardens in red, clay soils

Image courtesy of Wikipedia

Mimic what works in nature. Red, clay soils are very similar to the soils under tropical forests.

That is easier than you think because you have probably been fighting it. 

Stop being anal about eliminating "weeds", at least in the places where you haven't planted yet. That mat of Crabgrass (in the summer), Dead-nettles, Chickweed and volunteer turnips (in the cooler months) are busy keeping the nutrients in the biosphere. And since you cannot effectively bank it in the soil as humus, then that is really you only alternative.

Nutrient cycling as "an economy"

Economists look at two numbers when assessing the health of an economy: The money supply (the number of dollars in circulation) and the velocity-of-money.

Injecting funds into the economy by giving benefits to poor people has more POP! than giving it to wealthy people. Poor people don't hoard the money. They run out and spend it. Wealthy people are much more likely to park their money in bank accounts or bonds which doesn't keep the money in the high-velocity parts of the economy.

As a gardener or orchardist living in places with red, clay soils or blow-sand, you need to stop thinking of yourself as a banker but as a scheduler who makes sure that there is always a line of customers waiting to grab those nutrients before they leach away. 

7 comments:

  1. We do get invaders from tropical areas, chasing one another. Fire ants, then armadillos comes to mind. For plants, kudzu is an invader feeding off standing growth. Is there something coming after the kudzu, or a "scheduling" remedy? (I once ran over an armadillo 65 years ago, to my lingering regret.)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Also, the growing 'season' is a lot longer, allowing two crops a year if you want it. Also, flipping crops year to year helps rejuvenate the soil.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sweet potatoes, okra, cowpeas, melons, greens.

      Lots of good eatin'

      Delete
  3. Interesting to hear, gives me food for thought! This Tennessee chert has been a bitch! Mushroom compost and fresh horse fertilizer by the literal dump truck, barely makes a dent! The impact only lasts ayear or two, too! One of the locals has a great garden, asked his secret sauce: grass clippings. For 20 years, he's dressed his plants with the clippings bagged from his lawnmower. In the fall it gets tilled in with the leaves bagged up from mowing.
    At the end of the day, its been 20 years of adding organic tilth, not a secret, but the technique of gradually adding some every time the lawn gets mowed is the secret to his success(ful technique).

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It would be interesting to see how long that tilth and fertility lasted if he stopped giving it "sips" of lawn clippings.

      Delete
    2. Well from my limited (20 years) experience with gravelly glacier soils (and a few years of red clay in SC) and reports from Permies down in GA where red clay is common adding a lot of organic input is the solution.

      As that 1900's scientific farming book Farmers of 40 Centuries pointed out China and much of Asia has that Jungle soil-red clay issue and they managed to recycle enough organic materials to feed a massive population before oil-based fertilizers.

      After all your rich soil Joe comes from eons of being lake bottom that dried up a century or three ago.

      Also. Joe, inputs MUST exceed OUTPUTS of a bank account OR fertile garden soil is to be enriched.

      When that doesn't happen rich midwestern soil becomes a sandy mix that merely supports the plants as fertilizer, herbicides and pesticides get sprayed over them.

      Delete
    3. Check out https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terra_preta

      Char does not degrade with heat, moisture and contact with soil. Char (similar to activated charcoal) holds cations and keeps them available for growing plants.

      I am still waiting for Lucky to weigh-in.

      Delete

Readers who are willing to comment make this a better blog. Civil dialog is a valuable thing.